LSU’s loss to Texas ends its playoff hopes, but Lane Kiffin’s biggest problem goes way beyond finding a quarterback in 2027

The LSU Tigers fell to the Texas Longhorns on the final play, and the offseason fix everyone keeps selling for Lane Kiffin’s program looks a lot shakier than it sounds.

Add as preferred source on Google
Tigers Head Coach Lane Kiffin, The LSU Tigers take on Alabama. November 7, 2026; Baton Rouge, LA, USA; at Tiger Stadium.
Tigers Head Coach Lane Kiffin, The LSU Tigers take on Alabama. November 7, 2026; Baton Rouge, LA, USA; at Tiger Stadium. SCOTT CLAUSE/USATODAY Network / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

I’m officially worried for LSU. The Tigers’ loss to the Texas Longhorns was the final nail in the coffin, and LSU’s college football playoff opportunity was squashed the moment Raleek Brown crossed the goal line for Texas.

There’s plenty to dissect from that game, and much of it will shape the rest of LSU’s season. But I’m more interested in the broader picture, because I think the conversation around Lane Kiffin’s program is missing the part that matters most.

The expectations were always a little ahead of reality for Lane Kiffin’s first year

LSU entered the season with high expectations for Kiffin, and understandably so. He built a national-title-caliber team at Ole Miss with Trinidad Chambliss, even though that group didn’t get there. He walked into Baton Rouge with more resources than ever, and the way he left Ole Miss only added fuel to the narrative.

To be clear, I said many times that it took Kiffin a couple of years to get settled at Ole Miss, and I’m not changing that belief. The difference is he won’t get that same runway at LSU. There’s less breathing room in Baton Rouge, and the expectations are higher.

Now, I never bought that this was a national title team just because LSU beat down on Mississippi State and Auburn. Those wins told you the Tigers could handle the teams they should handle. They didn’t tell you this roster was ready to go toe-to-toe with the best in the SEC.

The quarterback isn’t the whole story

What concerns me is the notion floating around that LSU would have been just fine this year with a different quarterback and the noise grew even more surrounding Sam Leavitt. The thinking goes that it could be Husan Longstreet next season, or Landon Clark, or somebody out of the transfer portal, and once the Tigers get their guy, everything pulls together and looks pretty and amazing.

In the words of Lee Corso, “Not so fast, my friends.”

And you may say, Tegan, the offense is what lost them this game against Texas, so why wouldn’t a different quarterback fix it? It’s a fair point. Offensively, LSU failed on Saturday. But I’m more worried about the future on the other side of the ball when looking ahead to 2027.

Blake Baker’s future is the real decision Lane Kiffin has to make

The underlying conversation that needs to happen around LSU is about defensive coordinator Blake Baker. I assume Baker gets a head coaching job at a Group of Six or Power Four program, and when he does, Kiffin will face the most significant hire and decision of his time at LSU.

Because Baker has been incredible. The defense has not been the problem for the Tigers. They did their part against Texas. Yes, they gave up the final play, but they handed the offense every opportunity to salt that game away, and the offense couldn’t do it.

So think about what LSU looks like without Baker and without a lot of these veteran pieces. I look at Trey’Dez Green, Whit Weeks, and the rest of the experienced defenders who have carried this team. Say what you want about how this season unfolded, but that unit has been the one thing LSU could count on week in and week out.

Can LSU replace all of that? It’s entirely possible. The Tigers have every capability to do it, with the resources, the recruiting pull, and a head coach who knows how to build a roster. I’m not doubting that.

What I’m doubting is the idea that one quarterback solves everything. If Baker leaves and the veteran core walks out the door with him, LSU isn’t plugging one hole. It’s rebuilding an offense and a defense at the same time, under a head coach who no longer has the patience Ole Miss gave him.

That’s bordering on being called a rebuild. Not a reload.

I believe LSU is headed for more of a rebuild than a lot of people want to admit, and the hire Kiffin makes to replace Baker will decide whether this program is back in the playoff conversation next season or stuck answering the same questions a year from now.

Play A to Z Daily Games