Former Ohio State star calls out Ryan Day, state of the Buckeyes after the disappointment in Nebraska

Ohio State is at a new low point after giving Nebraska its first ranked win since 2016, and the Buckeyes now have former players calling out the program.

Brandon Little — Ohio State Buckeyes & Cleveland Browns News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Ohio State Buckeyes head coach Ryan Day reacts in the first half of the NCAA football game against the Nebraska Cornhuskers at Memorial Stadium on Nov. 21, 2026 in Lincoln, Nebraska. Samantha Madar/Columbus Dispatch / USA TODAY NETWORK via Imagn Images

The Ohio State Buckeyes entered their Week 12 matchup with the Nebraska Cornhuskers at 7-3 with a small chance at the College Football Playoff. That chance depended on Ohio State getting some help elsewhere. Those hopes are now gone after a 31-28 loss to Nebraska dropped the Buckeyes to 7-4.

Ohio State is in its worst spot since the 2011 season. The Buckeyes’ defense collapsed against Nebraska and allowed more than 370 yards. Now former players are calling out the program, that’s the point we’ve made it to. 

Michael Thomas calls out Ryan Day’s program

Michael Thomas played wide receiver at Ohio State from 2012 to 2015. The New Orleans Saints selected him in the second round of the 2016 NFL Draft, and he went on to earn multiple Pro Bowl and All-Pro honors in New Orleans. He’s a proven talent that’s roamed the campus in Columbus. 

Toward the end of the loss to Nebraska, Thomas took to X to share his thoughts on Ohio State coach Ryan Day and how the program prepares during the week:

“I’m very curious how Ryan Day runs the practices at the Woody Hayes Center because going off what we see on Saturday that s— soft asf.”

Thomas played under Urban Meyer at Ohio State, and that was a different era of college football. The sport hadn’t yet entered the NIL era, and things looked much different. Thomas won a national championship with the Buckeyes in the early stages of the College Football Playoff. Now he’s questioning whether Day’s program has gone soft.

Ohio State’s defense collapsed again

Thomas’ comments come after another game where Ohio State’s defense fell apart against an opponent that most considered inferior. The Buckeyes are in their worst position in more than a decade, and it’s hard to argue with Thomas right now.

Ohio State is a big step down from where it was a season ago. The Buckeyes came up short in the College Football Playoff last year, but they looked the part of a contender. This year’s team hasn’t come close to that standard.

The disappointment also extends to the offense. This is the third and final year of Jeremiah Smith in Columbus, and his last season with Ohio State has turned into a major letdown. A generational talent at wide receiver deserved a better final run than a four-loss season with no playoff berth, especially with a freshman quarterback playing good enough. 

Ohio State has to own this one. The loss to Nebraska ended any hope of a playoff run, and it gave former players a reason to speak up publicly. When players who were terrific in Columbus start calling out the program, it tells you how far things have slipped.

Day’s program will face plenty of questions over the coming weeks. How Ohio State responds to the criticism, and whether the defense can show any fight to close the season, is going to be worth watching.

Play A to Z Daily Games