3 winners and 5 losers from Steelers’ loss to Eagles: DK Metcalf just cemented himself as the worst trade in franchise history
The Pittsburgh Steelers have now lost back-to-back games since coming out of the bye. A few players shined against the Eagles, and the list of losers runs from the field all the way up to the front office.
Another week, another loss for the Pittsburgh Steelers. Pittsburgh came out of its bye week riding high at 6-2 and looking like a true AFC contender. Two straight losses later, the Steelers look like pretenders, and frankly, as fraudulent as they come.
The loss to the Philadelphia Eagles had a little bit of everything: an offensive line meltdown, a game-sealing defensive lapse, and a wide receiver ejection. There were still a few bright spots. Let’s get into this week’s Steelers winners and losers.
Steelers winners vs. Eagles
EDGE Alex Higsmith
I don’t know how many sacks Alex Highsmith would have finished with if he hadn’t gotten injured. He played only two possessions and still walked away with two sacks, including a strip sack on Philadelphia’s opening drive.
The Steelers face a short turnaround with a Black Friday matchup against the Denver Broncos, so his status is worth watching. Either way, Highsmith was dominant while he was out there.
S Robert Spears-Jennings
The rookie safety has been thrust into the lineup because of some complications in the Steelers’ safety room, and he made the most of his chance. Coming out of halftime, Robert Spears-Jennings forced a fumble on the kickoff.
Pittsburgh couldn’t turn that into points because the offense was stuck in the mud for most of the day, per usual. That doesn’t take away from a great play by Spears-Jennings.
WR Max Hurleman
This was the Max Hurleman game. Part of that came from what happened with DK Metcalf (more on that shortly), but Hurleman earned every bit of his spot here.
He opened the game with a strong return, made multiple catches over the middle of the field, and hauled in a huge contested touchdown that pulled the Steelers within three. It didn’t end up mattering, but Herliman was the brightest spot on the field for Pittsburgh.
Max Hurleman stats vs. Eagles
- 6 receptions
- 61 receiving yards
- 1 TD reception
Steelers losers vs. Eagles
Offensive line
I could single out Spencer Anderson, who was horrible all day long, but the entire offensive line deserves to be on this list. The unit allowed five sacks to an Eagles defense that had struggled all season.
It hasn’t been good enough for two weeks now. Beyond the sacks, the Steelers can’t run the football to save their lives. Whatever happened over the bye, this group needs to get back to its pre-bye form in a hurry. The offensive line is a major problem in Pittsburgh.
HC Mike McCarthy
Before getting to the man of the hour, let’s look at the men who enabled him, starting with Steelers coach Mike McCarthy.
No run game. No accountability for DK Metcalf or the wide receiver room. No ability to push the ball downfield. The offense looks static, and dare I say, Matt Canada-esque. That starts with the head man and supposed offensive architect.
GM Omar Khan
Steelers general manager Omar Khan traded away George Pickens and brought in Metcalf. While Pittsburgh struggled, Pickens went crazy against the Tennessee Titans, a week after he posted his best game of the season. Metcalf, meanwhile, finished with more penalties than catches.
It goes beyond that trade. The secondary is a mess, and the offensive line still looks horrible despite the multiple free agent and draft assets the Steelers have poured into it. Khan has not done a good job as GM, and it’s showing on the field right now.
CB Jamel Dean
Jamel Dean is only here because of the final defensive play, but it was a costly one. Dean is a veteran cornerback, and the Steelers paid him a hefty amount to come in and make plays in big moments.
It was third-and-6 with the game on the line. All Dean had to do was play to the sticks, rally, and make the tackle. That doesn’t guarantee a win, but it gives the offense a fighting chance to go down and tie or win the game. Instead, he gave up an easy pitch and catch to a third-string quarterback who had struggled all day.
WR DK Metcalf
Now, the man of the hour. Metcalf ended the game with two penalties, one catch, and one ejection after back-to-back personal fouls, including an eye poke on Eagles defensive back Cooper DeJean.
He’s probably going to get fined and could be suspended, which would make it the second time in as many years with the Steelers that Metcalf has been suspended.
That’s the worst part. It’s one thing if Metcalf is simply bad, and outside of one or two games, he has been. But when you’re bad, a headache, a distraction, and you’re getting kicked out of games, there’s no defending it.
The way I see it, it’s safe to say DK Metcalf has officially gone down as the worst trade in the history of the Steelers.

