2 winners and 6 losers from Steelers’ embarrassing loss against Bengals: Cincinnati just made Pittsburgh take a look in the mirror
The Pittsburgh Steelers had two weeks to prepare for a Cincinnati Bengals team coming off an international trip, and the result was one of the ugliest nights in franchise history. Here are the winners and losers.
The Pittsburgh Steelers got their teeth kicked in by the Cincinnati Bengals on Sunday Night Football. I’ll say it plainly: this was one of the most embarrassing losses in the history of Steelers football, bar none.
There is a lot to break down, so we are going to sort through the wreckage with winners and losers from Sunday night. Fair warning, the winners list is short.
Winner: Jaylen Warren
The only reason Warren lands here is his mentality. It doesn’t matter if Pittsburgh is down 30 or up 30. He runs just as hard and plays just as hard, and I saw that from him all night long. How many of his teammates showed that same edge? Not many.
Winner: Pat Freiermuth
Muth made a miraculous catch in garbage time, and he was one of the few bright spots in the passing game. He battled all night long, and that was a day after he was listed as questionable with an illness. Freiermuth tends to always show out against the Bengals, and he added another TD on Sunday.
Offensive loser: The offensive line
The offensive line: This unit generated no push in the run game, and it couldn’t pass protect to save its life. Let’s be honest about Cincinnati’s pass rush. It isn’t that great, and the Bengals tried to trade for help at the deadline and came up empty. Against the Steelers, it looked like the second coming of the Eagles team that won the Super Bowl a couple of years ago. I don’t know what got into the offensive line, but it was awful.
Offensive loser: Mike McCarthy
To wrap up the offensive side, the blame starts at the top with the offense’s architect, Mike McCarthy.
Think about the circumstances. The Steelers had two weeks off coming out of the bye. Cincinnati was coming back from an overseas game. And the Bengals’ defense is mediocre at best. This is the performance Pittsburgh put up in that spot? It is inexcusable and unacceptable, and it falls on the man drawing it up.
Defensive losers: Asante Samuel Jr. and the pass rush
Asante Samuel Jr.: The cornerback was picked on left and right, just like we saw the first time these teams met. He eventually got benched for Daylen Everette, who didn’t have a good game either, but Samuel is the one who belongs on this list. He returned later and it was bombs away to Chase for six.
T.J. Watt: As much as I hate to do it, Watt has to be here. Amarius Mims completely shut him down and took every cent of Watt’s lunch money. It wasn’t close. Watt was having one of his better seasons as of late, and Mims was dominant against him anyway.
Alex Highsmith: He wasn’t any better on the other side. I know Orlando Brown Jr. is another good tackle, but Highsmith is supposed to win that matchup, especially when Cincinnati isn’t giving him a ton of chips or double teams. It was silence from the entire pass rush unit, and those two especially.
Defensive loser: Patrick Graham
Our final loser has to be Patrick Graham. This is back-to-back meetings with the Bengals, earlier in the season and now, where Graham has had zero answers for Joe Burrow.
To be fair to Graham, I understand this Cincinnati offense could win a Super Bowl and might be one of the best statistical offenses we’ve ever seen in the NFL. But the Steelers already played them and beat them. They had multiple weeks to prepare, and the Bengals were coming off an international game. Then Burrow threw for 300 passing yards and three touchdown passes in the first half.
Joe Burrow stats vs. Steelers on SNF
- 35/44 passing (79.5 percent completion percentage)
- 409 passing yards
- 4 touchdowns passing
The bottom line is that embarrassing isn’t the word, and neither is disappointing. It is beyond that. How bad the Steelers’ defense was, and how bad the entire team was on Sunday Night Football, is unfathomable.

