Playoffs? Yes, the Dallas Cowboys could somehow be NFC East favorites after Week 11 and it’s the likeliest scenario

The Dallas Cowboys have bigger problems than their playoff odds right now. But the NFL Playoff Predictor shows how quickly one Week 11 slate could reshape the NFC East race.

Mauricio Rodriguez — Dallas Cowboys News Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Nov 15, 2026; Arlington, Texas, USA; Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott (4) practices before the game against the San Francisco 49ers at AT&T Stadium.
Nov 15, 2026; Arlington, Texas, USA; Dallas Cowboys quarterback Dak Prescott (4) practices before the game against the San Francisco 49ers at AT&T Stadium. Kevin Jairaj-Imagn Images

Playoffs!? What are you talking about, playoffs!?

I realize plenty of people who root for the Dallas Cowboys don’t even want to hear about their postseason chances. Others do, and the truth is the Cowboys aren’t out of the NFC East race. So I fired up A to Z Sports’ NFL Playoff Predictor to see where Dallas stands heading into Week 11 and how a few results could shake up the playoff picture.

Cowboys’ path to the playoffs runs through the NFC East

The biggest takeaway has been clear for a while. If the Cowboys make the playoffs, it will be by winning the division.

Their odds of making the postseason and their odds of winning the NFC East are identical. Dallas has a 31% chance to do either, according to the predictor, because one leads directly to the other.

The New York Giants still have the upper hand in the division with a 53% chance to win it. The Washington Commanders, believe it or not, inserted themselves into the conversation with their win over the Giants last week. At 3-5-1, Washington has a 15% chance to take the NFC East.

Meanwhile, the Philadelphia Eagles are all but out of it at 2%.

How Week 11 could reshape the division race

Let’s start with the Cowboys’ own matchup. Dallas faces the 1-8 Tennessee Titans, a game it has a strong chance to win. A victory would only slightly bump the Cowboys to a 37% chance to make the playoffs and a 36% chance to win the division.

That’s a nice jump, but the real swing comes from a game Dallas isn’t even playing in.

The Giants host the 7-2 Jacksonville Jaguars, one of the most balanced teams in the NFL. I’ve always compared the Jaguars to the San Francisco 49ers in that I don’t see a fatal flaw on that roster. Jacksonville has a strong rushing attack and a good quarterback, and it’s simply a well-rounded team.

If the Jaguars win that game, the picture changes quite a bit. Both the Cowboys and Giants would climb above 40%, with Dallas at 42% to win the division and New York at 41%.

The Cowboys would suddenly be (very) slight favorites to take the NFC East.

Now let’s simulate the rest of the division for the heck of it. The Commanders face the Cincinnati Bengals, and I have Cincinnati winning that one. I also have the Pittsburgh Steelers beating the Eagles.

In that scenario, the Cowboys’ chances rise to 45%. It’s a small bump, but it keeps them narrowly ahead of the Giants, who would sit at 44% to win the NFC East.

One week could flip the script once again.

A missed opportunity and bigger concerns

To be fair, Dallas could be in a much better spot right now. Had the Cowboys beaten the 49ers, their odds of winning the division would be considerably higher, especially since that was a game they weren’t expected to win.

This is going to be a week-to-week story, and we’ll track it every week here at A to Z Sports using the NFL Playoff Predictor. It’s a great tool, and you can use it yourself to simulate your own playoff scenarios.

I’m not going to lie to you, though. If you’re a Cowboys fan, there are bigger concerns than just stacking enough wins to sneak into the postseason. With the way this defense has played, getting there will be tough, and doing anything once they arrive is another question entirely.

Plenty of fans will ask themselves what they even want out of a playoff trip. But I can guarantee a coaching staff on the hot seat will do its very best to get there. Perhaps that’s why the Cowboys are admittedly looking into a change to the coaching staff. And once you’re in the playoffs, you never know.

For Week 11, the numbers are clear. The Cowboys could finish the weekend as favorites to win the NFC East, or at least neck and neck with the Giants at 45% to 44%.

That would be pretty wild, wouldn’t it?

Play A to Z Daily Games