The Detroit Lions can still win the Super Bowl without Aidan Hutchinson, and here’s why I believe that

Losing Aidan Hutchinson makes Detroit’s Super Bowl pursuit much harder, but it doesn’t have to end it. Between an improving defense, an explosive offense and a wide-open NFL, there’s still reason to believe the Lions can win it all.

Mike Payton — Detroit Lions Beat Writer
Add as preferred source on Google
Nov 15, 2026; Munich, DEU; Detroit Lions quarterback Jared Goff (16) throws during the first quarter against the New England Patriots at Allianz Arena. Mandatory Credit: Kirby Lee-Imagn Images Kirby Lee

The Detroit Lions lost Aidan Hutchinson to what looks like a rough injury Sunday against the New England Patriots in Munich, Germany. NFL insiders Adam Schefter of ESPN and Ian Rapoport of NFL Network reported that it’s feared to be a torn ACL. The Lions haven’t confirmed anything, so I’m not going to tell you that’s what it is.

But if Hutchinson is out for the rest of the season, the biggest question I’m getting from Lions fans is simple. Is it over? Can Detroit still win a Super Bowl?

I took all of Sunday and most of Monday to think about it. My answer is no, it’s not over.

Is it going to be a lot harder? Yes. It’s harder for the Lions to win a Super Bowl now than it was a few days ago, when Hutchinson was healthy and playing at an All-Pro level.

Why the Lions can still win it all

Here’s the thing. Winning a Super Bowl isn’t always about what happens in the regular season.

Sometimes the best team wins. Last season, the Seahawks were clearly the best team in the NFL, and they won the Super Bowl. It isn’t like that every year, though.

I always bring up the 2011 New York Giants because they’re the perfect example. They finished 9-7 and barely made the playoffs. They had a bottom-of-the-league defense. Then they got hot at the right time and beat a 13-3 Patriots team in the Super Bowl.

New York had talent. It just didn’t put everything together until the end, and the end is the only time that matters if you’re good enough to make the playoffs. The Lions are a much better team than those Giants were. They’re also sitting on top of the NFC North, the best division in football.

This also feels like the most wide-open the NFL has been in a long time. The 49ers looked great until they nearly lost to a bad Cowboys team. The Bills look good, but their defense is allowing a lot. Nobody is running away with this thing.

The defense isn’t the same unit it was in September

I get it. The first four games of the season are burned into Lions fans’ minds, and you’re waiting for the other shoe to drop.

I’m going to say the same thing I said then. The problem wasn’t personnel. It was coaching. Defensive coordinator Kelvin Sheppard was putting players in horrible positions. Detroit played too much zone and blitzed way too much, and teams picked it up easily.

Since the schematic change in Week 5, this has been one of the best defenses in the league. The Lions aren’t going back to the things that clearly failed. That would be malpractice at the highest level.

Losing Hutchinson and Jack Campbell hurts. Those are the two biggest household names. But defensive tackle Alim McNeill is having an All-Pro-type season. Rookie defensive tackle Tyleik Williams is one of the best nose tackles in the league. Edge rusher Derrick Moore has four sacks in the last two games and keeps getting better.

The depth on the edge is a concern. I think the Lions would be wise to grab a veteran like Haason Reddick or Joey Bosa if one is out there.

In the back end, cornerback Roger McCreary was electric in Munich. He earned a game ball, was the Lions’ highest-graded defender, picked off a pass, and already has nine pass breakups. Safety Brian Branch is playing at the same elite level he always has. Chuck Clark has been strong, too.

Detroit could theoretically get cornerback D.J. Reed back Sunday against the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, and safety Kerby Joseph could be activated Tuesday. Reed is the 10th-highest-graded corner in the NFL according to Pro Football Focus, and he’s been elite since Week 5. We’ll learn more when Lions coach Dan Campbell speaks Tuesday and the team returns to practice Wednesday.

The offense can carry Detroit

Then there’s the offense. Running back Jahmyr Gibbs could break LaDainian Tomlinson’s single-season rushing touchdown record. He could run for 2,000 yards. By my math, he’d need about 139 yards per game to break Eric Dickerson’s rushing record, which doesn’t seem out of reach for him.

The offensive line has been one of Pro Football Focus’s highest-ranked units all season. Amon-Ra St. Brown is at the top of his game. Jameson Williams and Sam LaPorta are playing good football. The tight ends aren’t getting many targets, but they’re blocking at a high level in all these creative alignments.

This offense already beat a Vikings defense that people compared to the ’85 Bears. It can beat anyone.

I know some fans think the Lions had to make a trade. Midseason trades for big-name players have led to a Super Bowl maybe three or four times in the last 15 years. Ask Bears fans how the Khalil Mack trade went.

Next up is Tampa Bay, which has a good defense, and then Chicago on Thanksgiving. Come out of this stretch 3-0, and Detroit sits at 9-2 with its playoff ticket nearly punched. After that come winnable games against the Titans and Giants, plus three divisional road games.

It’s not going to be easy. The Lions will have to manufacture pass rush by committee and work as hard as they possibly can. But it’s not over. We’ll see.

Play A to Z Daily Games