‘What the hell’s going on around here?!’—ESPN’s NFL Draft gurus duel over the latest 2027 projection for the Miami Dolphins
The Miami Dolphins’ 2027 NFL Draft plans could go any number of ways. ESPN’s big wigs recently went toe-to-toe debating which road to take.
The Miami Dolphins‘ road ahead is tough to forecast. There’s plenty of good storylines from the youngest roster in football. But there’s also plenty of forks in the road ahead that are yet to be determined.
The next biggest one is what Miami will ultimately do with their high draft choice in the 2027 NFL Draft. Fans are split. Jeremiah Smith. Quarterback X. Colin Simmons. But, as it turns out, not even the big dogs can agree. ESPN recently tabbed NFL Draft analyst Jordan Reid to conduct a 2027 NFL mock draft — only to tango with Mel Kiper Jr. about Miami’s pick. To quarterback or not to quarterback…that is the question.
ESPN’s Mel Kiper Jr. & Jordan Reid tango over what the Miami Dolphins should do in the 2027 NFL Draft
Reid has the New York Jets jumping the Dolphins in order to draft Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker — giving up the No. 4 and 13 picks in this year’s first round plus a future 3rd-round pick in the process. Then, at No. 3, Reid had the Dolphins drafting Texas pass rusher Colin Simmons. He’s an electric talent and a potential strong fit for Hafley’s scheme as a SAM backer and speed rusher off the edge. Versatility makes him an attractive fit for Hafley.
Kiper was having none of it.
“What the heck are we doing, Jordan? No CJ Carr? No CJ Carr to the Miami Dolphins, you got Mestemaker to the Jets, you got Josh Allen in this division, you got Drake Maye in this division and we’re sitting here with Colin Simmons over CJ Carr and Darian Mensah? Jordan! What the hell’s going on around here?!”
They’re just like us! See? This is, at it’s core, the thing everyone is going to have differing opinions of. It’s the very thing Reid followed up with after being asked about the pick: Is CJ Carr worth a top-3 pick in the NFL Draft?
Carr is going to have time to ultimately forge that answer for himself in the weeks and months ahead. Some would currently say yes, like Kiper Jr. and Field Yates. Others would so no. The opinions are going to be vast — although only Miami Dolphins general manager Jon-Eric Sullivan’s opinion on the subject will ultimately matter if this hypothetical comes to be what Miami s faced with.
There’s a lotta ball game left, as they say. Expect plenty of debate, from the reaches of ESPN all the way down to your next door neighbor.

Miami Dolphins News
