Steelers’ loss on Sunday Night Football proves Pittsburgh is back in the spot fans hoped to have escaped with a new head coach
The Pittsburgh Steelers came out of the bye at 6-2 with real reasons for optimism. One ugly night against Joe Burrow and the Cincinnati Bengals changed the tone around this team, and former Steelers HC Mike Tomlin didn’t sugarcoat it.
The Pittsburgh Steelers got demolished by the Cincinnati Bengals on Sunday Night Football. The final score was 38-18, and a 20-point margin doesn’t come close to capturing how lopsided this blowout loss was for Pittsburgh.
Bengals quarterback Joe Burrow completed 35-of-44 passes for 409 yards and four touchdown passes. He had already thrown for more than 300 yards and three touchdowns by halftime. This game was arguably over halfway through the first quarter.
Speaking after the game for NBC, former Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin put it plainly:
“The first thing you have to acknowledge is they [Steelers] got smashed. They got smashed tonight. They ran into a buzzsaw.”
Why this loss stings more than most
Coming into Sunday, the Steelers had legitimate reasons to feel good. They were 6-2 coming off a bye week, and the defense was arguably the best in the league over the previous four weeks.
Even if Pittsburgh lost to a red-hot Cincinnati team, the expectation was that it would at least be competitive. A close game would have shown the Steelers could still win the AFC North and make a real run in the playoffs.
This game did the exact opposite.
Burrow is arguably the hottest quarterback in the league, so some fans could live with him putting up big numbers. The hope was that the offense could answer. It simply wasn’t there.
So you go from being excited about what this offense and defense could do to wondering whether a one-and-done playoff exit would be a good outcome. After Sunday’s performance, it’s hard to picture this team winning a playoff game. Which is the exact same spot the Steelers have been in for the past decade.
Steelers offensive stats vs. Bengals
- 222 total yards
- 120 passing yards
- 3.8 yards per play
- 5/13 on 3rd down
- 3 sacks allowed
The downfield passing game failed its biggest test
We have talked about this concern ad nauseam. Would Pittsburgh have enough answers when it needed a downfield passing attack?
The answer against the Bengals was absolutely, positively not.
Yes, DK Metcalf caught a touchdown of 30-plus yards late. To me, that was garbage time, and it doesn’t change anything. For the majority of the game, Cincinnati sold out against the run and dared the Steelers to beat them vertically.
The Bengals essentially told Metcalf and rookie Germie Bernard, whose game isn’t built on winning vertically, to go down the field and make plays. Pittsburgh couldn’t do it.
That is the part that should worry everyone in the building. Cincinnati’s defense is mediocre at best. If the Steelers can’t punish that unit through the air, what happens when they face better defenses in January?
What has to change for Pittsburgh
The path forward requires a lot to go right.
The Steelers need to get back to the drawing board on offense. Metcalf has to find a way to reinvent himself as a downfield threat. Getting Michael Pittman Jr. and Roman Wilson back in the lineup would help bring this passing game back to life.
Patrick Graham’s defense also needs to figure out how to keep Burrow from going scorched earth if these teams ever meet again. The group that looked elite for a month had no answers for him.
Unless Pittsburgh finds those fixes, I believe this loss could be remembered as the night the Steelers’ season ended for all intents and purposes. A 6-2 start bought this team some cushion, but Sunday showed exactly what happens when an opponent takes away the run and forces the Steelers to win through the air.

